Sunapee Harbor Didn't Replace The Anchorage. It Split It In Two.
For decades, if you wanted the whole Sunapee Harbor experience in one building, you went to The Anchorage. Dinner, drinks, live music on the deck, boats tying up right outside the door. It's also the building where, as harbor regulars have told the story for years, Aerosmith's Steven Tyler and Joe Perry first crossed paths. That's the kind of detail that turns a restaurant into a landmark.
The Anchorage is gone now. If you've walked down Main Street this season and wondered why the harbor suddenly has two new names instead of one obvious replacement, the answer says something real about how this waterfront actually works today. The old building didn't get a successor. It got divided, and the two businesses that came out of that split are each doing a smaller job than the Anchorage tried to do, which is exactly why they're working.
Here's the sequence, pieced together from harbor gossip, business filings, and a lot of watching storefronts change hands. When The Anchorage closed, its building at 71 Main Street sat available at the same time a small startup brewery called Hoptimystic was looking for a foothold in Sunapee. Hoptimystic moved in as a pop-up in 2024, testing the harbor crowd out of the old Anchorage space before relocating to a second temporary spot the following season in the Prospect Hill Antiques and Art Gallery building.
While Hoptimystic was still finding its footing, the original Anchorage building got a permanent tenant of its own: The Blue Canoe, a new lakeside restaurant that took over 71 Main Street and turned it into a sit-down dining room again, this time under different ownership and a different name. Hoptimystic, meanwhile, kept moving until it landed on a permanent, year-round tasting room on River Road, with a deck that runs along the Sugar River instead of the open lake.
So the math is simple. One landmark building. Two businesses. Neither one trying to be everything the Anchorage was.
This is the part that's easy to miss if you're just scanning a list of new restaurant names. Hoptimystic doesn't serve food. It can't, under its current license, and the brewery is upfront about it: bring your own. That sounds like a limitation until you notice what's happening around it. A few doors down, Fenton's Landing sells tacos. Stacy's Smoothies & Coffee Bar sells smoothies. The town's own summer concert series, the Sunapee Summer Shakedown at The Landing, is built explicitly around that arrangement, pointing concertgoers toward tacos from Fenton's, smoothies from Stacy's, and beer from Hoptimystic, all under one evening of music.
That's not a workaround. That's the harbor figuring out that a cluster of specialists beats one generalist. The Anchorage tried to be the kitchen, the bar, and the music venue at once, and by most accounts from longtime patrons, something in that formula had stopped working well before it closed. What replaced it isn't a single business doing the same three jobs better. It's several smaller businesses doing one job each, close enough together that you can walk between them in an evening.
Hoptimystic has picked up recognition for exactly this kind of focus. The brewery was named 2026 Lake Sunapee Region Chamber of Commerce Rookie Business of the Year and placed as runner-up in a regional Best of the 603 vote this year. Those aren't the kinds of honors that go to a place trying to be all things to all customers. They go to a place that does one thing and does it consistently.
If you've been away from the harbor for a season or two, here's what else has settled in around the Anchorage story:
None of these are large operations. Each one is narrower in what it offers than The Anchorage ever was. Together, they cover more ground than the old single restaurant did, because they're not competing with each other for the same dinner table. They're dividing the evening up.
If you're reading this in late September, you're catching the harbor at its hinge point. Boating season is winding down, and several of these businesses run on a summer clock that's about to shift. Stacy's Smoothies operates seasonally and typically closes as the lake traffic drops off. Fenton's Landing has historically wound down its full schedule around Columbus Day weekend before easing into a quieter winter rhythm. Hoptimystic, now a permanent fixture rather than a pop-up, settles into a shorter weekly schedule in the colder months, open Thursday through Sunday instead of daily.
None of this is a story about the harbor slowing down for good. It's the same rhythm Sunapee Harbor has always had, boats in the water from Memorial Day to Columbus Day, then a quieter stretch until spring. What's different this year is that the businesses riding out that rhythm are more specialized than the ones that used to anchor the harbor, no pun intended. A brewery with no kitchen and a dedicated restaurant a few doors down can each scale their hours to match demand in a way one do-everything restaurant never could.
The next time someone asks what happened to The Anchorage, the honest answer isn't "it closed and something else moved in." It's that the harbor tried something different: instead of finding one business to fill one big building's old role, it let that role split into pieces, each one small enough to do well. A brewery on the Sugar River. A restaurant back in the original Main Street building. A taco counter, a smoothie window, a cheese shop across the street. It's a different shape than the harbor used to have, and if the last two seasons are any indication, it's a shape that holds up better.
If you're already living near Sunapee Harbor, none of this changes your commute or your property taxes. But it's worth knowing the actual story behind the storefronts you pass, especially the one with the Aerosmith history that isn't a restaurant anymore.
If you're thinking about what a home near this stretch of the lake is actually worth in today's market, or you're weighing a move to be closer to it, Sell With Durell can walk you through what's changing on the real estate side of Sunapee, not just the restaurant scene. Request a free home valuation and get a straight answer, no pressure attached.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
